The short answer
Jamestown came first. Settlers reached the Jamestown site in Virginia in May 1607. The Mayflower reached Cape Cod in November 1620, about 13 years later.
Jamestown in May 1607
The Jamestown settlement was founded by the Virginia Company of London. Three ships, the Susan Constant, the Godspeed and the Discovery, reached the Virginia coast in late April 1607. The settlers went ashore on Jamestown Island in mid-May. Jamestown is generally considered the first lasting English colony in North America, since the earlier Roanoke attempts had failed. Read about the three ships.
The Mayflower in November 1620
The Mayflower left England on September 6, 1620, with 102 passengers. After a crossing of 66 days, it reached Cape Cod on November 11. That day, the adult men aboard signed the Mayflower Compact, an agreement for self-government. The group settled at Plymouth in December.
For the voyage’s early problems and the companion ship that was left behind, see the Speedwell.
Why the Pilgrims ended up in New England
The Mayflower Compact describes the voyage as an effort to plant a colony in “the Northern Parts of Virginia.” The Pilgrims had planned to settle in that region, but storms and the ship’s course took them to Cape Cod instead. Because they had landed outside the area covered by their permission, they needed a new patent, which they were still waiting for when they signed the Compact.
Some accounts say Virginia, with its established colony, would have been an easier place to land. The sources do not settle that question.
Early English colonies in order
| Colony | Date | Ships | Outcome |
|---|---|---|---|
| Roanoke (in present-day North Carolina) | Settlers arrived 1585 and 1587; the second group vanished by 1590 | Small fleets | The colony was lost |
| Jamestown (Virginia) | Settlers reached the site in May 1607 | Susan Constant, Godspeed, Discovery | Survived, though the early years were grim |
| Plymouth (Massachusetts) | Settlers landed in November and December 1620 | Mayflower; Speedwell left behind | Survived, though about half died in the first winter |
| Massachusetts Bay | Winthrop fleet arrived at Salem in June 1630 | Arbella and about ten other ships | Grew into a larger colony |
For the ships behind each colony, see the Roanoke voyages, the Jamestown ships, and the Arbella and the Winthrop fleet.
Who survived the first years
Both Jamestown and Plymouth lost many settlers early on. For Plymouth, the figures are in how many of the 102 Mayflower passengers survived. For a wider look at the ships, see colonial ships to America.