The short answer
The Speedwell was the smaller of the two ships the Pilgrims used to start their voyage to America in 1620. She leaked repeatedly. Repairs at Dartmouth did not solve the problem, and after a second leak beyond Land’s End, the group gave up on her. Some passengers moved to the Mayflower, the Speedwell turned back to England, and the Mayflower sailed on.
Why the Pilgrims had two ships
The Pilgrims were Separatists who had lived for about 12 years in Leiden, in the Netherlands, before deciding to make the move. In the summer of 1620, the Speedwell carried the Leiden group from Delfshaven in the Netherlands to Southampton in England.
There they were to meet the rest of their passengers and the Mayflower, a larger ship that had been chartered for the voyage. The Mayflower’s master was Christopher Jones. The plan called for both ships to sail together.
The first leak and the repairs at Dartmouth
Soon after the ships got under way, the Speedwell began to leak. William Bradford, who later wrote an account of the colony’s early years, recorded that the master of the smaller ship said she was too leaky to keep going. Both ships put into Dartmouth. There, the Speedwell was searched “from stem to stem,” and several leaks were found and mended. Bradford described the cost as “great charge and loss of time.”
When the repairs were finished, the workmen judged her “sufficient,” and the ships set out again with good hopes.
The second leak and the parting
The ships sailed again, and about 100 leagues beyond Land’s End the smaller ship’s master reported that the Speedwell was leaking so badly that the crew “could scarce free her with much pumping.”
Bradford records that the leaders then decided which passengers and supplies to move onto the Mayflower, and which people would go back. The two ships parted. The Speedwell turned back toward England, and the Mayflower went on.
Who moved to the Mayflower, and who went home
Some passengers moved from the Speedwell to the Mayflower, and others went back to England. The sources reviewed for this article do not give a firm number, so this article does not offer one.
What happened to the Speedwell
She was left in England. The sources reviewed here do not give a reliable account of her later history, so this article does not say how her career ended.
Why the leaks mattered
Wooden ships could leak when their seams opened in heavy seas. The Speedwell’s problems were serious enough that the group chose to continue with the Mayflower alone.
The Mayflower had its own trouble. Plimoth Plantation reports that a main beam cracked in a storm halfway across the Atlantic. The passengers had brought a “great iron screw,” which helped raise the beam back into place. The Mayflower finally got under way on September 6, 1620, and reached Cape Cod on November 11. For the passengers who sailed on her, see how many of the 102 passengers survived.
For what life was like aboard the Mayflower, see how the Pilgrims went to the bathroom. For the wider set of early ships, see colonial ships to America.