The short answer
Roanoke was not reached by one fleet. A series of expeditions between 1584 and 1590 used small fleets, and each depended on navy or privateer ships for supplies and passage. Individual ship names are thinly recorded, so this article names only the ships it can support.
1584: The scouting voyage
Sir Walter Raleigh held a royal charter to colonize North America. In 1584 he sent a reconnaissance under Philip Amadas and Arthur Barlowe, with two ships. They reached Roanoke Island in July that year and returned to England with two Algonquian-speaking men, Manteo and Wanchese.
1585: Grenville’s fleet and the first colony
The next expedition was larger: a fleet of seven ships under Sir Richard Grenville. In the summer of 1585 it left about 100 men on Roanoke Island under Ralph Lane. Grenville sailed back to England, promising to return with supplies. The colony was short of food, and relations with local peoples worsened.
1586: Drake’s visit and the colony that sailed away
In the summer of 1586, the English privateer Francis Drake stopped at Roanoke on his way home from raiding Spanish holdings in the Caribbean. Lane and the colonists, short of supplies and with no relief in sight, sailed back to England with Drake’s fleet.
A relief fleet sent by Grenville arrived shortly after. It found the settlement empty and left 15 men behind to hold the fort. When the next group arrived in 1587, those men were gone.
1587: White’s settlers and the pilot who would not sail on
John White led about 117 colonists, including women and children, on a small fleet that left England in late April 1587. The fleet’s pilot, Simon Fernandez, had also worked the 1585 voyage. He refused to take the colonists farther south to the Chesapeake, citing the late season. The colonists were put ashore on Roanoke Island in July 1587.
1587 to 1590: The ships that did not come back
White sailed for England in late August 1587 to bring back supplies and reinforcements. He expected to return within months. Instead, war with Spain and the crisis of 1588 meant that many ships were requisitioned for national defense, and White could not find passage.
In 1590 he finally secured a place on a privateering fleet that agreed to carry him and some supplies to Roanoke. The privateers were more interested in raiding Spanish shipping, and the fleet did not reach the Outer Banks until mid-August.
August 1590: The return and the search the ships could not finish
On August 18, 1590, White went ashore at Roanoke. The settlement was empty. The palisade was still standing, and the houses had been taken apart rather than destroyed. The word CROATOAN had been carved into a post. There was no Maltese cross, the sign the colonists had agreed on to show they were in distress.
White’s party tried to search Croatoan Island, but storms forced the ships to give up the search, and they returned to England. The next English attempt at a colony, Jamestown, is covered in the Jamestown ships of 1607.
What the ships tell us about the mystery
The ships were central to the story because they were the only way out. The colonists could not leave on their own. Each stage of the Roanoke voyages depended on the weather, the navy, and the decisions of pilots and captains.
The gap between the 1587 departure and the 1590 return lasted about three years. Much of the mystery rests on that gap, and on what happened to the colonists while no ship came.
The surviving records name few of the ships, and some names in popular accounts cannot be checked against primary sources. Where a name is uncertain, this article leaves it out. For the wider context of early English colonies, see which came first, Jamestown or Mayflower.