The short answer
About 50 of the 102 passengers who boarded the Mayflower in England survived the first winter in Plymouth, in 1620–21. Sources give figures from about 50 to 53. The counts differ because records are incomplete and some births and deaths are uncertain. Roughly half of the passengers died that first winter.
The 102 passengers
The Mayflower carried 102 passengers from England. They included members of a religious congregation who had lived in Leiden in the Netherlands, seeking religious freedom, along with other English people looking for a better life or financial gain. Historians often call these groups the “Saints” and the “Strangers.”
The crew of about 25 to 30 men sailed the ship but is not counted among the 102 passengers. The crew returned to England in the spring of 1621. For how the Mayflower’s crossing began, see the Speedwell article.
Deaths at sea
Very few people died during the 66-day crossing. Sources agree that only one person died at sea, but they disagree on who it was. The Mayflower Society names William Butten, a young servant to Dr. Samuel Fuller. Plimoth Plantation describes a sailor who had been unkind to the passengers.
Two children were born on the voyage or soon after. Oceanus Hopkins was born at sea. Peregrine White was born after the ship reached Provincetown.
Dorothy Bradford at Provincetown
One more death happened before the settlers went ashore. The Mayflower Society reports that Dorothy, the wife of William Bradford, fell overboard at Provincetown Harbor.
The first winter
The settlers lived aboard the ship while they rowed ashore and built houses, beginning in December 1620. Cold, wet work and poor food left many people sick. Plimoth Plantation describes a “general sickness” of colds, coughs and fevers. Some accounts also mention scurvy and pneumonia. By March 1621, there were enough houses for everyone to live on land.
For more on the illnesses of the period, see disease at sea.
Why the numbers differ
Several factors lead to different totals:
- Incomplete records. Some passengers’ status and family relationships are poorly documented.
- Births. It is not always clear how children born on the voyage or after arrival should be counted.
- Deaths at sea. Sources agree on the number but disagree on the name of the person who died.
- Unreliable online sources. Some social media posts and Q&A sites give confident numbers without citing a source. Check the original record before using a figure.
Families that lasted
The Mayflower Society reports that 26 families among the passengers are known to have left descendants. Some families were especially hard hit. The Tinker, Turner and Tilley families were among those who perished. Several children were orphaned that first winter, including Mary Chilton, Samuel Fuller, Priscilla Mullins and Elizabeth Tilley.
For the sequence of voyages that brought the Pilgrims to Cape Cod, see which came first, Jamestown or Mayflower.