What was the Battle of Jutland?
The Battle of Jutland, fought on 31 May and 1 June 1916, was the largest naval battle of the First World War. It was also the only full-scale clash between the main battle fleets of Britain and Germany. The Grand Fleet of the Royal Navy, under Admiral Sir John Jellicoe, met the German High Seas Fleet, under Vice Admiral Reinhard Scheer, in the North Sea off the coast of Jutland in Denmark.
Neither side destroyed the other’s main fleet, so the battle did not settle the war at sea. It did have lasting consequences for both navies.
The forces
Britain brought roughly 150 ships to the battle, and Germany about 100. Both fleets were built around the dreadnought concept: battleships armed with heavy guns of a single calibre, supported by battlecruisers, cruisers, and destroyers. Jellicoe’s Grand Fleet held the main battleship force. Vice Admiral David Beatty commanded the faster battlecruisers. Scheer’s scouting force was led by Vice Admiral Franz von Hipper’s battlecruisers.
The opening: battlecruisers and magazine explosions
The battle began in the afternoon of 31 May, when Beatty’s battlecruisers met Hipper’s off the Danish coast. The two groups exchanged fire at long range. Beatty then steamed south, drawing the Germans towards the main British battle fleet.
This phase was costly for the British. HMS Indefatigable and HMS Queen Mary were destroyed by magazine explosions. HMS Invincible later blew up in a similar way, with heavy loss of life, and the rear admiral commanding the battlecruisers, Horace Hood, was killed with her. The Germans also lost ships in this phase. Hipper’s flagship, Lützow, was badly damaged and was lost later in the battle.
The main battle
When Jellicoe deployed the Grand Fleet into a line across the German path, Scheer turned away. The fleets then fought in the evening light. Historians have debated whether Jellicoe should have pressed harder at that point, because a decisive result was within reach but the light was failing.
As darkness fell, the German fleet slipped through the British destroyer screens and crossed astern of the main British fleet. Night actions between destroyers and cruisers took place along the way. By the morning of 1 June the two fleets had separated, and the High Seas Fleet returned to its bases.
Losses
The commonly cited figures are these. Britain lost 14 ships, including three battlecruisers, three armoured cruisers, and eight destroyers, with about 6,100 men killed. Germany lost 11 ships, with about 2,550 men killed. Because the British losses were larger, many contemporaries read the battle as a German tactical success.
Who won?
The battle is still debated. The High Seas Fleet never again sought a full fleet battle with the Grand Fleet, and Britain kept control of the North Sea. The blockade of Germany remained in place. Many historians therefore see Jutland as a strategic British success, even though the tactical result was disappointing for Britain. The heavier British losses and the missed chance to destroy the German fleet are the main points critics raise.
What the battle tested
- Dreadnought design. The loss of three battlecruisers showed that British magazine arrangements were dangerous. The Royal Navy made changes to protect magazines after the battle.
- Gunnery and fire control. Both fleets relied on rangefinders and fire-control systems to hit distant targets. Their accuracy in the battle varied widely, and the battle showed how hard it was to hit moving ships at long range.
- Destroyers and torpedoes. Torpedo attacks by destroyers forced the battle fleets to turn repeatedly. They also made night fighting a central part of fleet actions.
- Reconnaissance and signals. Both sides relied on scouting by ships, seaplanes, and airships, and on wireless signals. Misreading the enemy’s position and course was a recurring problem.
Aftermath
The British blockade of Germany continued, and the German fleet stayed largely in port for the rest of the war. Germany’s leaders later turned to unrestricted submarine warfare in 1917, in part because the surface fleet could not break the blockade.
Jutland is often taken as the culmination of the pre-war Anglo-German naval race, the point at which the dreadnought fleets finally met in battle. It remains a reference point for the battleship era. Japan’s Yamato and Musashi were built on the same belief that heavy guns would decide fleet battles, although by then carrier aircraft had begun to challenge that belief.