Steamships and Liners

RMS Lusitania: Why the Liner Sank in 1915 and What It Changed

Why did the Lusitania sink? A German U-boat torpedoed the Cunard liner off Ireland on 7 May 1915, and a second explosion followed. Facts and debates.

On this page
  1. Short answer: a torpedo, then a second explosion
  2. The Lusitania
  3. The war zone and the warnings
  4. The attack on 7 May 1915
  5. The second explosion
  6. The death toll
  7. Why the sinking mattered
  8. What remains debated

The RMS Lusitania was a Cunard passenger liner torpedoed by a German U-boat off the south coast of Ireland on 7 May 1915. She sank in about 18 minutes, and 1,198 of the 1,959 people aboard died. Her loss is one of the most debated events of the First World War, and the reasons it happened are still discussed.

Short answer: a torpedo, then a second explosion

The U-boat U-20 fired a single torpedo into the Lusitania’s starboard side. A second, much larger explosion followed inside the ship. The second blast is the part of the sinking that has been debated most, because its cause is not settled. The ship went down quickly and listed heavily, which made it hard to launch many of her lifeboats.

The Lusitania

The Lusitania was built for Cunard and launched in 1906. She was a fast passenger liner on the North Atlantic route between Liverpool and New York, and she was the sister of the Mauretania. For the Mauretania’s history, see RMS Mauretania: History of the Blue Riband Liner.

In 1915 she was carrying passengers and cargo on a voyage from New York to Liverpool. Her cargo included ammunition, which became central to the later debate.

The war zone and the warnings

In February 1915 Germany declared the waters around the British Isles a war zone, in which enemy merchant ships could be attacked. Passenger ships were included in the declaration. Before the Lusitania sailed from New York, the German Embassy published warnings in American newspapers, reminding travellers that the British Isles were a war zone.

These warnings are often cited in the debate. Supporters of the German position argue that passengers were warned. Critics argue that the attack on a passenger liner was unlawful in any case.

The attack on 7 May 1915

The attack was carried out by U-20, commanded by Kapitänleutnant Walther Schwieger. The torpedo struck the starboard side of the Lusitania near Old Head of Kinsale, off the coast of County Cork. The sinking happened quickly. The ship listed heavily, which made it hard to launch many of her lifeboats.

The second explosion

After the torpedo struck, a second explosion ripped through the ship. The cause has been argued over for more than a century. Explanations have included the ammunition in the cargo, coal dust in the ship’s bunkers, and problems with the boilers. No single explanation has been accepted by all historians.

The second explosion matters because it may explain why the ship sank so fast. Whether it was caused by the cargo or by something else affects how the sinking is judged, so readers should treat any single explanation with care.

The death toll

Of the 1,959 people on board, 1,198 died. Among the dead were 128 Americans. The scale of the loss, and the number of women and children among the dead, made the sinking one of the most shocking events of the war.

Why the sinking mattered

The sinking caused anger in the United States, and the American government protested to Germany. Public opinion in America became more hostile to Germany, and the sinking is often cited as one of the events that increased pressure on the United States to join the war. Historians debate how much weight to give it compared with other factors.

Germany later restricted its submarine attacks for a time, partly in response to American protests. That restraint did not last, and the campaign returned in a more intense form in 1917.

What remains debated

Several questions remain open. The most important are:

  • What caused the second explosion, and whether the cargo was a major factor
  • Whether the ship was a legal target under the rules of war at the time
  • How much the warnings in American newspapers should count in judging the attack

Readers who want the wider context can compare the Lusitania with the Empress of Ireland, which sank in the St. Lawrence in 1914 in a very different accident. See The Empress of Ireland (1914).

The complete guide to steamships and liners

Steamships and Iron Hulls: How the Industrial Revolution Changed Ships
Read the guide

Keep exploring

Guides from other topics

All topics →