On 29 May 1914 the Canadian Pacific liner Empress of Ireland sank in the St. Lawrence River after a collision with the Norwegian collier Storstad in thick fog. More than 1,000 people died. Her loss is less widely remembered than the Titanic’s, although it happened only two years later and only weeks before the First World War began.
Short answer: a collision in fog
The Empress of Ireland was sailing from Quebec to Liverpool when she was struck on her starboard side by the Storstad in fog near Rimouski, Quebec. Most passengers were asleep in their cabins. The liner sank within about 15 minutes, and only a few lifeboats could be launched because of the heavy list. The exact number of people aboard and the exact death toll vary by source, but more than 1,000 people are generally recorded as having died.
The Empress of Ireland
The Empress of Ireland was a passenger liner built in Scotland in 1906 for the Canadian Pacific Railway’s shipping service. She sailed between Canada and Britain, carrying first-, second- and third-class passengers as well as mail and cargo. Her master was Captain Henry Kendall.
Canadian Pacific used the ship on the St. Lawrence route, which was an important link between the interior of Canada and Britain.
The voyage of May 1914
The ship left Quebec on 28 May 1914, bound for Liverpool. She carried several hundred passengers, a large mail and general cargo. Among them was a large group of Salvation Army members travelling to an international conference in London.
Thick fog on the river was a serious hazard, and ships of the period had no radar to help them find each other in fog.
The collision and the sinking
The collision happened in the early hours of 29 May, at about two in the morning. The Storstad was a Norwegian collier, a cargo ship carrying coal, and she was heading up the river in the opposite direction. She struck the Empress of Ireland on the starboard side, below the waterline.
The liner listed heavily and sank quickly. Most of the passengers were in their berths, and few of them had time to reach the upper decks. Because of the list, only a few lifeboats could be launched.
Early reports and the death toll
The early newspaper reports made several mistakes. Some named the wrong ship, reporting that the Empress of Ireland had collided with a German liner called the Hanover rather than the Storstad. Early casualty estimates were also too low or too high at different times. One early Montreal report gave an estimate of 800 dead, which was later revised upward as more information arrived.
The final death toll, which is generally given as more than 1,000, was higher than the first estimates. This pattern is common in disasters of the period, when communication was slow and information came in pieces.
Captain Kendall and the Storstad
Captain Henry Kendall survived the sinking. He had already gained public attention in 1910, when he recognised the fugitive Dr Hawley Crippen aboard the Montrose, a Canadian Pacific ship, and helped lead to his arrest.
The Storstad was badly damaged but did not sink, and the collision was investigated as an accident in fog. The question of who was at fault was examined by inquiries in Canada and Britain.
Salvage and the recovered mail
The Empress of Ireland was reported to be carrying a large amount of silver bullion, and the underwriters arranged for salvage work on the wreck. Some of the mail was recovered from the wreck. It was dried and marked with a cachet reading “Recovered by divers from the wreck of SS Empress of Ireland”, then sent on to its recipients. Covers from the recovered mail are still collected today.
Why the disaster is less remembered
The sinking came just weeks before the outbreak of the First World War, and the news was soon overshadowed by the war. It also followed the Titanic by only two years, and the public had strong feelings about the Titanic disaster. Those factors help explain why the Empress of Ireland is less familiar today, even though her loss was one of the worst in Canadian maritime history.
For another North Atlantic liner lost in 1914 and 1915, see RMS Lusitania: Why the Liner Sank in 1915 and What It Changed. For the wider era of steam and iron shipping, see Steamships and Iron Hulls.