The 39 men Columbus left behind were killed. When Columbus returned to the settlement on his second voyage in November 1493, he found the fort burned and the men dead. The main account blames the men’s own behaviour toward the local Taíno people, which provoked an armed response. Some details of what happened are disputed, and the sources do not settle every question.
Who the 39 men were and why they were left
On Christmas night 1492 the Santa María ran aground off the north coast of Hispaniola. Columbus had the wreck’s timbers used to build a fort, which he named La Navidad, meaning “the Nativity”. Before sailing for Spain in January 1493, he left 39 men there, with supplies, to hold the site and to gather gold and trade with the local people.
The men were a mix of sailors and others from the fleet. The fort was meant to show that the Spanish could hold a base on the island, and to prepare for the next voyage.
What Columbus found in 1493
Columbus returned to Hispaniola in November 1493 with a much larger fleet of 17 ships. He found that the fort had been burned and that the men were dead. The accounts that survive from the period report that none of the 39 were found alive, and no survivors are recorded.
Why it happened: the main explanations
The most widely accepted account is that the men’s behaviour provoked the local Taíno. According to the later accounts, the men spread out across the island, demanded gold and food, and took Taíno women. Local leaders responded with an attack that destroyed the fort.
Several accounts name Caonabó, a powerful Taíno chief from the interior, as responsible for the attack. Other accounts mention Guacanagarí, a chief who had been friendly with Columbus, and the involvement of his people in events. The sources do not agree on every detail.
Some historians also suggest that the men fought among themselves. Disorder within the group may have made them easier to attack. This explanation is less well documented than the conflict with the Taíno.
Columbus’s own reports presented the Taíno as hostile, and historians read his accounts with care. Later writers, including the Dominican friar Bartolomé de las Casas, drew on Columbus’s papers and on other sources to tell the story in more detail.
What the sources do not settle
- The exact site. Archaeologists have debated where La Navidad stood, and no single location is accepted by every historian.
- The attack itself. The number of attackers, the timing and the course of the fighting are not recorded in detail.
- The men’s last months. The records of their daily lives are fragmentary, so their behaviour is known mostly from accounts that were written by others.
What it changed
The discovery shaped Columbus’s plans for the second voyage. He did not try to hold La Navidad again. Instead he founded a new settlement, La Isabela, in 1494 on the north coast of Hispaniola, in what is now the Dominican Republic. It was an early attempt at a permanent European town in the Americas, and it struggled for supplies and food.
Related reading
For the ships that carried the men to the Caribbean, see Niña, Pinta and Santa María. For what the crew ate on the crossing and at the fort, see what Columbus’s crew ate. For the ship types of the period, see the ships of the Age of Exploration.